Halide substitution in phenethylammonium spacer cations (X-PEA, X = F, Cl, Br) is a facile strategy to improve the performance of PEA based perovskite solar cells (PSCs). However, the power conversion efficiency (PCE) of X-PEA based quasi-2D (Q-2D) PSCs is still unsatisfactory and the underlying mechanisms are in debate. Here, the in-depth study on the impact of halide substitution on the crystal orientation and multi-phase distribution in PEA based perovskite films are reported. The halide substitution eliminates n = 1 2D perovskite and thus leads to the perpendicular crystal orientation. Furthermore, nucleation competition exists between small-n and large-n phases in PEA and X-PEA based perovskites. This gives rise to the orderly distribution of different n-phases in the PEA and F-PEA based films, and random distribution in Cl-PEA and Br-PEA based films. As a result, (F-PEA)MAPbI (MA = CHNH, n = 4) based PSCs achieve a PCE of 18.10%, significantly higher than those of PEA (12.23%), Cl-PEA (7.93%) and Br-PEA (6.08%) based PSCs. Moreover, the F-PEA based devices exhibit remarkably improved stability compared to their 3D counterparts.